Call: (413) 349-4100     Address: 5 School St. Hatfield, MA

Fishtales Menu


Onion Rings $6.99

Had cut, battered, golden fried to order, chipotle dipping sauce


Oysters on the 1/2 Shell $12.99

(6) chilled fresh oysters served with lemon and cocktail sauce

Mozzarella Sticks $8.99
Lightly breaded fried mozzarella cheese, served with house marinara

Chicken Wings $6.99
Bone - In or Boneless served with celery and blue cheese dressing. 
medium, hot, BBQ, teriyaki, garlic, salt & pepper, or sweet chili


Bacon Wrapped Pork Skewer $8.99

Crispy bacon wrapped pork loin on a stick drizzled with peanut sauce


Raw Bar Sampler $16.99

(2) Oysters on the half shell, (2) chilled shrimp, a lobster claw and crabmeat

Crispy Calamari $8.99
Lightly breaded and fired marinara sauce

Fresh Maine Steamers Market Price
Served with broth and drawn butter

Stuffed Mushroom caps $8.99
Mushrooms stuffed with our house made seafood stuffing and topped with mozzarella cheese

Spinach & Artichoke Dip $8.99
A warm crock of creamy spinach tender artichokes and melted cheeses served with warm tortilla chips

Shrimp Cocktail $10.99
(8) Fresh chilled colossal shrimp with a zesty cocktail sauce

Fishtale's Nachos   (sm) $6.99 / (lg) $9.99
Corn tortilla chips topped with jalapenos, blacked olives, diced tomato's, taco meat &
melted Monterey jack cheese, sour cream and salsa


Potato Skins $7.99

Local potato skins fried crisp and filled with cheddar cheese and crispy bacon, served with sour cream

Maryland Crab Cakes $6.99
(2) House made cakes loaded with crab meat, grilled to perfection, citrus aioli



Mediterranean Chef Salad $12.99

Ham, pepperoni, provolone and parmesan cheese over field greens with cucumbers, tomatoes, hardboiled

egg, olives and a zesty vinaigrette

Caesar Salad $7.99
Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with parmesan cheese, crisp garlic croutons & just the right
amount of house made dressing, sliced egg and anchovies

Chipotle Salad $12.99
Chopped iceberg lettuce, field greens mixed with tomatoes, scallions, diced cucumbers, shredded cheddar
cheese and tortilla points topped with grilled chicken & chipotle dressing

Wedge Salad $12.99
Iceberg lettuce wedge topped with tomatoes, chopped bacon, gorgonzola cheese & grilled chicken

Scallop BLT Salad $16.99
Seared BBQ sea scallops and garlic croutons piled high over a bed of mixed greens,
sliced tomatoes and hickory smoked bacon with ranch dressing

Lobster Cobb Salad $20.99
Chopped iceberg, romaine lettuce layered with tomatoes, avocado, chopped bacon,
sliced egg and gorgonzola cheese and fresh chilled lobster meat

School Street Salad $15.99
Marinated char-grilled sirloin tips, sautéed mushrooms, tomatoes, cucumber and bleu cheese crumbs served on a
bed of mixed greens with balsamic vinaigrette

Salad Toppers $6:
Grilled Chicken / Sirloin tips / Cajun Shrimp / Salmon / Calamari


New England Clam Chowder 
cup $3.99 / bowl $4.99

Lobster Bisque
cup $4.99 / bowl $6.99

Soup Du Jour
cup $2.99 / bowl $3.99


All of our baked seafood entrees are served with soup of the day or salad
Substitute clam chowder $1.50
Choice of potato and seasonal vegetable

Boiled Lobster market price
Fresh 1 1/4 Ib Maine lobster with drawn butter

Stuffed Haddock $17.99
Baked haddock filets layered with our house made seafood stuffing topped with our signature breadcrumbs baked

golden and topped with a creamy lobster sauce

Swordfish $18.99
Fresh North Atlantic swordfish sautéed with olive oil, lemon, Chablis capers, garlic &
tender artichokes

Baked Haddock $16.99
Pick your pleasure, baked topped with our traditional crumbs, Pan seared with lemon and white wine

or Putanesca style, oven roasted topped with an aromatic blend of garlic, roasted tomatoes, capers

anchovies and Kalamata olives

Sea Scallops $18.99
Have them your way!  Baked with our traditional crumbs, Cajun blackened to perfection or baked with smoked bacon
& Vermont cheddar cheese

Salmon $18.99
Choose between a Salmon Filet braised in butter. Cape Cod cranberries, maple syrup and soy sauce

  or     Grilled with lemon., salt and pepper

Stuffed Shrimp $18.99
Baked jumbo shrimp with seafood stuffing and herb butter crumbs

New England Clambake market price
1 1/4 Ib steamed lobster, steamers & a crock of clam chowder

Lazy Lobster $27.99
Fresh picked tail and claw meat sauteed in butter with a touch of sherry


All of our fried entrees are served with French fries and homemade coleslaw

Fish and Chips $13.99
Fresh haddock filets, dipped in beer batter and deep-fried

The Fish Tale Platter $22.99
Heaping portion of batter fried fish, deep sea scallops, gulf shrimp & clam strips

Fresh Sea Scallops $19.99
Lightly breaded, golden fried sweet plump & juicy

Clam Strips $14.99
Lightly breaded, golden fried served with homemade tartar

Whole Clams market price
Golden fried whole belly clams

Fried Shrimp $15.99
Lightly breaded Gulf Shrimp, golden fried served with zesty cocktail sauce


Catfish Pontchartrain $17.99

Breaded fried filet of catfish, topped with Louisiana Pontchartrain stew made from tender artichokes,

capers, garlic, crabmeat, tomatoes, lemon, white wine and butter


All dinner entrees served with soup of the day or salad
Substitute Clam Chowder $1.50
Choice of potato and seasonal vegetable

School Street Meatloaf $13.99

A sought after treasure, all beef meatloaf with rich brown gravy served with mashed potatoes

Smothered Tips $16.99
Our juicy marinated sirloin tips, smothered with peppers, onions & mushrooms
Add Gorgonzola Cheese $2

Jambalaya $18.99
Shrimp, chicken, sausage, peppers and onions, in a mild creole sauce
tossed with rice and served with garlic bread

New York Sirloin $21.99
12oz New York Strip steak, topped with garlic herb butter and crispy fried onion straws
*make it surf and turf* add stuffed shrimp $3 each

Seafood Fra Diablo $18.99
Morsels of Swodfish, Salmon, Shrimp, Scallops and Mahogany clams sauteed with peppers,
onions, mushrooms and a spicy red sauce with rice


Honey Pork Chops $16.99

Twin center cut boneless chops, pan seared and glazed with honey mustard, topped with asiago gratin


All pasta dishes are served with salad and garlic bread

Chicken and Sausage Penne $16.99
Chicken, sausage, mushrooms, baby spinach, basil, garlic, tomatoes and mozzarella
cheese served on a nest of Angel Hair

Pick a Parmesan $14.99
Golden fried chicken breast, Spicy Italian sausage or classic meatballs topped with marinara sauce
& mozzarella cheese served on a nest of angel hair

Chicken and Broccoli $16.99
Sliced grilled breast of chicken, broccoli, pappardelle pasta in your choice of garlic and oil or parmesan cream

Seafood Scampi $22.99
Gulf shrimp, diver scallops and Maine lobster sautéed in olive oil with garlic, capers, fresh diced tomatoes
and angel hair pasta

Chicken Francaise $16.99
Boneless chicken breast dipped in a light egg batter, sautéed with lemon, white wine and butter nestled over pappardelle pasta


Seafood Mac $25.99

Sweet Maine Lobster meat, shrimp and scallops folded into a creamy 5 cheese béchamel baked with a buttery Ritz cracker topping

***consuming raw or under-cooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs, may increase your health risk of food-borne illness,
especially if you have medical conditions ***


All sandwiches served with chips and a pickle
Upgrade to Fries $1
Sweet potato fried $2

Signature Burger $9.99

Swiss, jack, and cheddar cheeses, fried onion strings, pickles, dijon horseradish sauce on a country roll

Western Burger $9.99
All beef burger served on a country roll with BBQ sauce, bacon and crispy fried onion strings

Cape Cod Reuben $9.99
Golden-fried haddock, cole slaw, Swiss cheese and 1,000 Island dressing on grilled marbe rye

Black & Blue Burger $10.99
Cajun spiced beef burger topped with gorgonzola cheese on a toasted kaiser roll
with fresh sliced tomato and crisp lettuce

California Chicken Club $8.99
Grilled chicken breast, avocado mayo, crisp bacon, lettuce and tomato on toasted whole grain wheat bread

Chicken Cordon Blu $8.99
Golden fried chicken breast, shaved ham, Swiss cheese and honey mustard on brioche bun

Classic Reuben Melt $9.99
Corned beef, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut on grilled marble rye

Bacon Burger Melt $9.99
Grilled black angus burger topped with crispy bacon, between a grilled cheese sandwich

Lobster Roll $15.99
Fresh chunks of chilled lobster meat gently tossed with celery & just enough
Mayonnaise on a soft roll with crisp iceburg lettuce

Hot Lobster Roll $18.99
Big chunks of freshly shelled lobster meat warmed in real butter and served on a soft roll, a New England tradition!

Meatloaf Burger Melt $9.99
Our own ground sirloin, blended with celery, onion, cheese and fresh herbs cooked on the griddle
sandwiched between two grilled slices of country white bread, smokehouse cheddar & mashed potatoes!


Baked potato $2.99
Sweet potato fries $3.99
French fries $1.99
Hatfield fires $2.99
Mashed potato $1.99
Potato wedges $1.99
Rice $1.99
Coleslaw $1.50
Side salad $2.99
Side caesar $4.99
Add bacon & cheese $1.50

Monday - Saturday 11:30-4pm
*with the purchase of a beverage*

Grilled Cheese $4.99
Grilled Ham & Cheese $5.99
Grilled Cheese and Tomato $5.99
Tuna Salad Sandwich $5.99
Tuna Melt $5.99
Bacon Lettuce and Tomato (BLT) $5.99
Soup of the Day and Salad $6.99
Soup of the Day and 1/2 Sandwich $6.99

Fish and Chips $5.59
Batter fried fish filet, french fries and coleslaw served with tartar sauce

Chicken Caesar $6.59
Sliced boneless chicken breast nested on top of our famous house Caesar salad with crisp

croutons and sliced hardboiled egg

Tuna Stuffed Tomato $5.59
Ripe Beefsteak tomato, stuffed with our fresh tuna salad, served on a bed of mixed greens

Grilled Hot Dog $5.59
1/4 pound Kayem dog served on a grilled New England style roll served with baked beans and potato salad

Sailor Burger $6.59
8oz Filet topped with seasoned crumbs served with potato and vegetable of the day

Atlantic Salmon $6.59
Fresh salmon filet, grilled or Cajun served with potato and vegetable

Sirloin Steak Tips $6.59
Smothered with peppers, onions and mushrooms served with potato and vegetable

Swordfish Steak Tips $6.59
Fresh cut, pan seared swordfish tips with potato and vegetable


After 4pm unless otherwise noted
w/ purchase of a beverage
Plate charge to split specials
see server for details

Grilled pork chops with applesauce, potato and vegetable $10
Roasted prime rib with potato and vegetable $14.99
ALL DAY: Twin lobsters with drawn butter $22

Prime rib or stuffed shrimp with potato and vegetable $12.99
Make it SURF AND TURF: prime rib, stuffed shrimp, potato and veggie $15.99
ALL DAY: Triple lobsters with drawn butter $MKT

Chicken parmigiana served over angel hair pasta $10
Shepherds Pie $10
ALL DAY: New England Clambake: Lobster, steamers, chowder, potato and vegetable $MKT

Batter fried fish n chips with coleslaw and tartar sauce $10

Corned Beef and Cabbage $10
ALL DAY: Twin lobsters with drawn butter $MKT

Steak Bake & Brew $10
Fire roasted 1/2 chicken and baked potato $10




Add Fries for $1

Add Sweet Potato Fries $2

Cheeseburger Deluxe- Black Angus burger, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayonnaise


Classic Meatball- Large italian meatballs with marinara sauce, grilled peppers, onions and cheese


Chicken Parmigiana- Boneless breaded chicken breast, marinara sauce, grilled onions and peppers and cheese


Chicken Cutlet- Batter fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and cheese


Sausage Cacciatore- Spicy Italian sausage, peppers, onions, marinara and cheese


Buffalo Chicken- Boneless breaded chicken, hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, and blue cheese dressing


Steak Bomb- Shaved steak, cheese, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and steak sauce

Cajun Shrimp- Gulf shrimp grilled with louisiana cajun spices, lettuce, tomato and green onion mayo



Small- $11.50      Large -$16.50     Party- $24.95

Combination- Pepperoni, Hamburger, Peppers and Onions

House Special- Pepperoni, Hamburger, Sausage, Peppers, Onions and Mushrooms

Shrimp Scampi- Grilled shrimp, Garlic, Lemon, Bacon and Extra Cheese

Buffalo Chicken- Diced Chicken, Buffalo Sacue, Blue Cheese and Extra Cheese


Create Your Own


cheese     7.50/11.95/18.95

1 topping    7.95/12.75/19.95

2 topping    8.95/13.50/20.95

3 topping    9.95/14.50/21.95

4 topping    10.25/15.50/22.95

5 topping    11.50/16.50/24.95


Toppings: Hamburger, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Bacon, Chicken, Anchovies, garlic, mushrooms, black olives, onions, green peppers, roasted red peppers, broccoli and tomatoes


FISHTALES Bar & Grill.

(413) 349-4100
5 School St. Hatfield, MA

View Menu >
Contact Us >


©     413-349-4100