Call: (413) 349-4100     Address: 5 School St. Hatfield, MA

Fishtales Menu


Onion Rings $7.99

Had cut, battered, golden fried to order, chipotle dipping sauce


Mozzarella Sticks $8.99
Lightly breaded fried mozzarella cheese, served with house marinara

Chicken Wings $8.99
Bone - In or Boneless served with celery and blue cheese dressing. 
medium, hot, BBQ, teriyaki, garlic, salt & pepper, or sweet chili


Crispy Calamari $8.99
Lightly breaded and fired marinara sauce

Fresh Maine Steamers Market Price
Served with broth and drawn butter

Stuffed Mushroom caps $9.99
Mushrooms stuffed with our house made seafood stuffing and topped with mozzarella cheese

Shrimp Cocktail $10.99
(8) Fresh chilled colossal shrimp with a zesty cocktail sauce


Maryland Crab Cakes $7.99
(2) House made cakes loaded with crab meat, grilled to perfection, citrus aioli



Caesar Salad $9.99
Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with parmesan cheese, crisp garlic croutons & just the right
amount of house made dressing, sliced egg and anchovies

Chipotle Salad $14.99
Chopped iceberg lettuce, field greens mixed with tomatoes, scallions, diced cucumbers, shredded cheddar
cheese and tortilla points topped with grilled chicken & chipotle dressing

Romaine Wedge $9.99
Romaine lettuce wedge topped with tomatoes, chopped bacon, gorgonzola cheese

Scallop BLT Salad $17.99
Seared BBQ sea scallops and garlic croutons piled high over a bed of mixed greens,
sliced tomatoes and hickory smoked bacon with ranch dressing

Lobster Cobb Salad $20.99
Chopped iceberg, romaine lettuce layered with tomatoes, avocado, chopped bacon,
sliced egg and gorgonzola cheese and fresh chilled lobster meat

School Street Salad $16.99
Marinated char-grilled sirloin tips, sautéed mushrooms, tomatoes, cucumber and bleu cheese crumbs served on a
bed of mixed greens with balsamic vinaigrette

Salad Toppers $6:
Grilled Chicken / Sirloin tips / Cajun Shrimp / Salmon / Calamari


New England Clam Chowder 
cup $3.99 / bowl $4.99

Lobster Bisque
cup $4.99 / bowl $6.99

Soup Du Jour
cup $2.99 / bowl $3.99


All of our baked seafood entrees are served with soup of the day or salad
Substitute clam chowder $1.50
Choice of potato and seasonal vegetable

Boiled Lobster market price
Fresh 1 1/4 Ib Maine lobster with drawn butter

Stuffed Haddock $17.99
Baked haddock filets layered with our house made seafood stuffing topped with our signature breadcrumbs baked

golden and topped with a creamy lobster sauce

Swordfish $18.99
Fresh North Atlantic swordfish sautéed with olive oil, lemon, Chablis capers, garlic &
tender artichokes

Baked Haddock $16.99
A Fishtales favorite! Always fresh North Atlantic haddock topped with our signature house made breadcrumbs, baked to perfection

Sea Scallops $20.99
Have them your way!  Baked with our traditional crumbs, Cajun blackened to perfection or baked with smoked bacon
& Vermont cheddar cheese

Salmon $18.99
Filet of Salmon dusted with lemon pepper, pan roasted and complimented with a touch of freshly made basil pesto

Stuffed Shrimp $18.99
Baked jumbo shrimp with seafood stuffing and herb butter crumbs

New England Clambake market price
1 1/4 Ib steamed lobster, steamers & a cup of clam chowder

Lazy Lobster $29.99
Fresh picked tail and claw meat sauteed in butter with a touch of sherry


All of our fried entrees are served with French fries and homemade coleslaw

Fish and Chips $14.99
Fresh haddock filets, dipped in beer batter and deep-fried

The Fish Tale Platter $26.99
Heaping portion of batter fried fish, deep sea scallops, gulf shrimp & clam strips

Fresh Sea Scallops $20.99
Lightly breaded, golden fried sweet plump & juicy

Clam Strips $15.99
Lightly breaded, golden fried served with homemade tartar

Whole Clams market price
Golden fried whole belly clams

Fried Shrimp $15.99
Lightly breaded Gulf Shrimp, golden fried served with zesty cocktail sauce



All sandwiches served with chips and a pickle
Upgrade to Fries $1
Sweet potato fried $2

Signature Burger $10.99

Swiss, jack, and cheddar cheeses, fried onion strings, pickles, dijon horseradish sauce on a country roll

Cape Cod Reuben $10.99
Golden-fried haddock, cole slaw, Swiss cheese and 1,000 Island dressing on grilled marbe rye

Black & Blue Burger $11.99
Cajun spiced beef burger topped with gorgonzola cheese on a toasted kaiser roll
with fresh sliced tomato and crisp lettuce

Grilled Chicken Sandwich $10.99
Grilled chicken tenders, American cheese, crisp lettuce and tomato

Classic Reuben Melt $10.99
Corned beef, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut on grilled marble rye

Bacon Burger Melt $10.99
Grilled black angus burger topped with crispy bacon, between a grilled cheese sandwich

Chilled Lobster Roll $16.99
Fresh chunks of chilled lobster meat gently tossed with celery & just enough
Mayonnaise on a soft roll with crisp iceburg lettuce

Hot Lobster Roll $18.99
Big chunks of freshly shelled lobster meat warmed in butter and served on a soft roll, a New England tradition!


Baked potato $2.99
Sweet potato fries $3.99
French fries $1.99
Hatfield fires $2.99
Mashed potato $1.99
Rice $1.99
Coleslaw $1.50
Side salad $2.99
Side caesar $4.99
Add bacon & cheese $1.50


After 4pm unless otherwise noted
w/ purchase of a beverage
Plate charge to split specials
see server for details

Traditional Meatloaf Dinner $10
Roasted prime rib with potato and vegetable $14.99
ALL DAY: Twin lobsters with drawn butter $MKT

Prime rib or stuffed shrimp with potato and vegetable $12.99
Make it SURF AND TURF: prime rib, stuffed shrimp, potato and veggie $15.99
ALL DAY: Triple lobsters with drawn butter $MKT

Pasta Night - choose from 3 different pasta dishes $10
ALL DAY: New England Clambake: Lobster, steamers, chowder, potato and vegetable $MKT

Batter fried fish n chips with coleslaw and tartar sauce $10

ALL DAY: Twin lobsters with drawn butter $MKT

Steak & Bake $12




Add Fries for $1

Add Sweet Potato Fries $2

Cheeseburger Deluxe- Black Angus burger, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayonnaise


Classic Meatball- Large italian meatballs with marinara sauce, grilled peppers, onions and cheese


Chicken Parmigiana- Boneless breaded chicken breast, marinara sauce, grilled onions and peppers and cheese


Chicken Cutlet- Batter fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and cheese


Sausage Cacciatore- Spicy Italian sausage, peppers, onions, marinara and cheese


Buffalo Chicken- Boneless breaded chicken, hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, and blue cheese dressing


Steak Bomb- Shaved steak, cheese, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and steak sauce

Cajun Shrimp- Gulf shrimp grilled with louisiana cajun spices, lettuce, tomato and green onion mayo



Small- $11.50      Large -$16.50     Party- $24.95

Combination- Pepperoni, Hamburger, Peppers and Onions

House Special- Pepperoni, Hamburger, Sausage, Peppers, Onions and Mushrooms

Shrimp Scampi- Grilled shrimp, Garlic, Lemon, Bacon and Extra Cheese

Buffalo Chicken- Diced Chicken, Buffalo Sacue, Blue Cheese and Extra Cheese


Create Your Own


cheese     7.50/11.95/18.95

1 topping    7.95/12.75/19.95

2 topping    8.95/13.50/20.95

3 topping    9.95/14.50/21.95

4 topping    10.25/15.50/22.95

5 topping    11.50/16.50/24.95


Toppings: Hamburger, Pepperoni, Ham, Sausage, Bacon, Chicken, Anchovies, garlic, mushrooms, black olives, onions, green peppers, roasted red peppers, broccoli and tomatoes


FISHTALES Bar & Grill.

(413) 349-4100
5 School St. Hatfield, MA

View Menu >
Contact Us >


©     413-349-4100